If you’ve been around MissPres for a while, you’ve know we’re big fans of “McAlester’s Field Guide” or more properly A Field Guide to American Houses. This was originally published in 1984, and I wore my paperback copy out by the time the updated and vastly expanded new edition came out in 2013 (it’s now out in paperback). I suggested then that every Mississippi preservationist should have one on their bookshelf, easily within reach to pull out and astound friends at dinner parties with your vast architectural knowledge.
The most helpful expansion in the new edition is the new stylistic guidance it gives for mid-century and even late-20th century houses. One short chapter is called “Monterey” in the “Eclectic Houses” section, and it’s given me a name to attach to several houses I had photographed because I thought they were interesting but didn’t know what to do with. Here’s how Virginia McAlester describes the Monterey style:
Monterey (1925-1955). Two stories, with low-pitched gabled roof (occasionally hipped); broad, dominant second-story balcony, usually cantilevered and covered by principal roof. . . . In Monterey houses, the balcony is generally the primary decorative feature on the house and extends the full width of the house–or the full width of the wing in a gabled-front-and-wing form.
The first one of this type I ever noticed was the Ross Barnett House in Belhaven. Yes, that Ross Barnett! Then, just a few months later, the Creekmore House on Old Canton Road was in the news when the Lefleur East neighborhood group wanted to use the house as a community house, so I went up there and lo and behold, it had that same cantilevered balcony. After that, it was like when you buy a certain brand of car, and then you start noticing them all over the place. Well, ok, so far, I’ve only photographed them in two other places, but I’m sure you eagle-eyed Mississippi preservationists will start pointing out all the Monterey style houses you know about.
This house in the Washington-Main Historic District in Greenville may not fully fit the definition because the balcony is not the primary decorative feature, but I thought I would throw it in for discussion. It’s also earlier (c.1919) than McAlester’s suggested range of dates. The MDAH Historic Resources Database describes it as Spanish in style.
McAlester also gives a brief history of the style (p.537):
The Monterey is a free interpretation of the Anglo-influenced Spanish Colonial houses of northern California. These blended Spanish adobe construction with pitched-roof, massed-plan English shapes brought to California from New England. However, the key identifying feature of the Monterey–the full-width cantilevered balcony (or occasionally two-story porch)–was derived from house forms built in the southeastern United States, the Caribbean, and the Bahamas. The 1834 Larkin House in Monterey, California is generally identified as the first of this distinctive form of early pitched-roof Spanish Colonial houses.
. . .
California architect Roland E. Coate, Sr., played a crucial role in reviving the style. Between 1929 and 1932 he wrote about the early Monterey homes, designed at least two homes in the Monterey, and won a prestigious Better Homes in America Award for an elegant Santa Barbara example. . . .
Some early examples from about 1925 to 1940 have Spanish detailing, while those from the 1940s and 1950s generally include only English Colonial details. A third, less common variation was sometimes called Creole French; these had decorative iron balconies inspired by the upper=level balconies found in the Vieux Carre in New Orleans.
I guess I’m unconvinced about the connection of the Monterey style to the Larkin House, which is an intriguing building but looks more like the Pitot House in New Orleans and other Louisiana Creole houses in Louisiana. For one thing, I don’t see the cantilevered balcony on the Larkin House. Far be it from me to question accepted architectural history, but what am I missing?
At any rate, one last Mississippi example, brought to you from the Google streetview: this post-WWII version with an iron balcony on Grand Avenue in Yazoo City fits that last Creole French sub-type that McAlester mentions.
Categories: Architectural Research, Greenville, Jackson, Yazoo City
This nugget in Bay St. Louis:
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sadly I think that has recently been remodeled out of existence.
A more modern spin – James T. Canizaro’s apartments in Belhaven, Jackson, MS.
Interesting! Here is a shot from the MDAH HRI db w/o all the foliage.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh wow, interesting connection! I love those buildings but didn’t even think about them in this context!
This solves a mystery for me. I asked My Dad Several times what inspired his design for the Kenwood apartments. On one occasion he mentioned Monterey CA and Spanish Colonial. It made no sense to me till now. Obviously there were other influences but it helps me understand.
LikeLiked by 2 people
What an offbeat post–and as usual, an excellent one!
On my most recent Delta trip I recall seeing a Monterey in the Creekmore House mode. I am trying to recall where exactly it was, since I didn’t get a picture, but it was on a nice drag with well maintained bigger homes.
Mississippi has much prettier ones than the one in Monterey!
Great collection of houses! Also, I love McAlester. Can’t go anywhere without it!
Funny, I lived right around the corner from the Barnett house for six years and never noticed that the balcony had no supports. Something about that house has always bothered me; one of those things I just can’t put my finger on.
I, for one, say no to either of the houses in Greenville being Monterey style; aren’t they both Spanish colonial?
I say the Greenville House looks more Mediterranean Revival (a catchall term from my stint in Florida), but since Monterey grew out of it perhaps it’s a transitional home.
there are many variants of spanish-influenced houses in hattiesburg; mr rosell has already briefly mentioned the parkhaven neighborhood–where a number are grouped on s. 22nd avenue. there must be one or two ‘monterey’ houses in town, too, but i can’t think of any offhand. such houses might look odd in mississippi–but i guess the deep south isn’t that far from mexico! they exist here in upstate ny(rochester area), where i live, but, yes, are visually quite odd when buried in our typical winter snows!
The Greenville home at 427 S. Main st. I would love the history of that home and who was the first owner of it. It was built in 1905 and was owned by the Phillips family for about the last 30 years or so. This is the only information that I have. If anyone can add to the history of this property it would be greatly appreciated. Thanks